Sunisa Lee steps up in Biles’s absence to win Olympic women’s gymnastics all-around

Simone Biles stands at just 4ft 8in tall yet her presence has loomed large over gymnastics for what feels like an eternity. Since 2013, she has won the women’s all-around title every single occasion she has been present. Over time, second place had become the only realistic goal for which any other gymnast could strive.

And so, in the wake of Biles’ withdrawal from the all-around competition in Tokyo, the only question to be answered as the rest of the world marched on to the arena was how the top gymnasts would react to this new experience of having a gold medal clearly within reach.

In such a mentally taxing sport, nerves and errors would be entirely understandable. Instead, each of the clearest medal contenders did every last thing they could to take the gold medal for themselves. The four highest qualifiers behind Biles took the top four places on the night; a remarkable 16 pressure routines between them without a fall. When the cards fell, Sunisa Lee of the United States nailed the floor routine of her life to mark herself as Olympic all-around champion.

With her score of 57.433, she edged out Brazil’s Rebeca Andrade, who scored 57.298 for silver, and Angelina Melnikova of the Russian Olympic Committee, whose 57.199 yielded a strong bronze – three enormous scores. Jessica Gadirova, meanwhile, became the first British woman to record a top-10 finish by taking 10th place as Jennifer, her twin sister, finished in 13th.

Lee has trodden a unique path to her distinction as Olympic all-around champion. The 18-year-old is the first Hmong American ever to be selected as an Olympian. Her route to Tokyo has been paved with tragedies and struggles; her father fell off a ladder just before the US national championships in 2019 and was paralysed from the chest down. She has lost an aunt and uncle to Covid-19. She spent much of the pre-Olympics stretch performing with a concerning ankle injury. Her perseverance and drive has allowed Lee to keep moving forward.

Both were in abundance throughout the spectacular final. The four leading gymnasts bounded into the arena determined to immediately register their impact. On her relatively weaker apparatus, Lee opened the final by sticking her double twisting Yurchenko vault for a score of 14.600. Andrade, one of the best vaulters in the world, responded by nailing a tremendous, difficult Cheng vault for 15.300 points. The Russians Melnikova and Vladislava Urazova remained tight to their rivals with two solid double twisting Yurchenko vaults of their own.

That tit-for-tat was how the final continued. Andrade pulled off her full difficulty bar routine, which Lee followed by nailing the most difficult uneven bar routine in the world, with its labyrinth of complex connections. Melnikova and Urazova, meanwhile, posted the third- and fourth-highest bars scores of the final.

The balance beam so often exposes nerves and separates the champions, yet one by one, they all refused to fall. On her best piece, 16-year-old Urazova scored a huge 14.200 and the others followed in turn, smoothing over their few tentative moments as they determinedly remained on the beam.

It all came down to the floor exercise, where the small details finally separated them. Urazova’s routine was not difficult enough. Melnikova gave away vital tenths on a spin. Andrade, who only had to match her qualifying score to win, twice stepped out of bounds. Lee performed to the very best of her ability, nervelessly nailing her landings and finishing with a score of 13.700, almost three tenths higher than in qualifying. It was enough.

This will be remembered as Lee’s night, but in truth it was a win for all. Andrade, 22, has long been one of the most talented gymnasts in the world. Yet in her six-year senior career, she has torn her anterior cruciate ligament on three separate occasions, her potential constantly stunted. She most recently did so in 2019 before the World Championships. She qualified for the Olympics only last month. Finally, she has had the preparation and the platform to demonstrate the breadth of her talent in a major final.

Rory McIlroy has praised American gymnast Simone Biles for joining tennis star Naomi Osaka in breaking the "taboo" on mental health in sport.

Four-time Rio gold medallist Biles withdrew from her scheduled defence of the women's all-around final on Friday, citing a desire to protect her mental health. Osaka, who lit the Olympic flame in the opening ceremony in Tokyo, lost in the third round of the women's singles following an eight-week break after pulling out of the French Open on mental health grounds.

Speaking after an opening 69 in the men's competition at Kasumigaseki Country Club, McIlroy said he understood "100 per cent" how Biles felt. "I live in the United States and anything that came on the TV with NBC or commercials about the Olympics, it was Simone Biles, it was Simone Biles' Olympics, right?" the former world number one said. "So to have the weight of, what is it, total six million people combined in the island of Ireland. You've got 300 whatever million, so the weight on her shoulders is massive.

"And just as I thought Naomi Osaka was right to do what she did at the French Open and take that time off and get herself in the right place, I 100 per cent agree with what Simone is doing as well. You have to put yourself in the best position physically and mentally to be at your best and if you don't feel like you're at that or you're in that position then you're going to have to make those decisions. I'm certainly very impressed, especially with those two women to do what they did and put themselves first."

McIlroy, who said he was not in a good place mentally after walking off the course during the Honda Classic in 2013, said he accepts it is "part of the job" to deal with the pressure and questions which come with trying to win the Masters and complete a career grand slam.

"There's been a few athletes that have really spoken up, Michael Phelps, Kevin Love, Naomi Osaka, Simone Biles. I mean the conversation, it's not taboo anymore. People can talk about it just as somebody has a knee or elbow injury, if you don't feel 100 per cent right mentally that's an injury too." PA

The bronze medallist, Melnikova, has a story of her own. Five years ago, aged just 16, she was not ready for the Olympics. She folded in the qualifying round, finishing in 22nd place and generated a reputation for mental frailty early on in her career. Her growth over the years has been a joy. In Tokyo, she led her young Russian team as they outscored the US with Biles in qualifying and then they repeated the trick in the team final. Now she has taken an individual medal herself.

As the gymnasts blazed through their four pieces, the Ariake Gymnastics Centre was relatively well populated with other gymnasts and delegates from each country, but it was generally quiet. Most cheered only when their own compatriots were on the floor.

But from the right-hand corner of the arena, the loudest voice was a familiar one. As she sat beside Jordan Chiles and Mykayla Skinner, Biles hollered for both of her teammates but also for other gymnasts she is friendly with from different countries, including Andrade and Melnikova, loudly cheering them on by name. It remains to be seen whether Biles will compete again, but the field has only improved over the years. This night was a reminder of how worthy they are, too.

• Download the Guardian app from the iOS App Store on iPhones or the Google Play store on Android phones by searching for 'The Guardian'.

• If you already have the Guardian app, make sure you’re on the most recent version.

• In the Guardian app, tap the yellow button at the bottom right, then go to Settings (the gear icon), then Notifications.

• Turn on sport notifications.

Related: Olympics: Sunisa Lee wins gold in women’s gymnastics individual all-around – live!