Bills coach Sean McDermott ripped for not challenging catch by Dalton Kincaid
Buffalo Bills head coach Sean McDermott has been criticized by fans for being too conservative. This one seemed like a no-brainer.
Buffalo trailed the Houston Texans 14-3 with 2:42 left in the second quarter. The Bills defense provided a spark, forcing a turnover on downs in the red zone. Buffalo's offense was stringing together its longest drive of the game - albeit 35 yards - and faced third-and-13 from the Texans' 49-yard line. Josh Allen had four completions on the possession after one completion in the entire game prior.
Tight end Dalton Kincaid appeared to make a spectacular catch on third-and-long. Kincaid dove for the ball and dragged his feet for a toe tap and he sailed out of bounds. Officials ruled Kincaid juggled the ball during the process.
Bills head coach Sean McDermott could've challenged the play. A catch ruling would've given Buffalo a first down at the Houston 32-yard line.
Instead, McDermott opted to punt the ball back to the Texans, who also would receive the ball to start the second half. Houston got the ball another time before halftime and Ka'imi Fairbairn made a 50-yard field goal as time expired to take a 17-3 lead at halftime.
Refs rule this catch incomplete saying Kincaid was juggling the catch but it looks like he has control... Bills punt. #BUFvsHOU pic.twitter.com/ydTrj1H8Mw
— Rate the Refs App (@Rate_the_Refs) October 6, 2024
Bills fans not happy with Sean McDermott's decision not to challenge
McDermott!!!!!!!! wtf!!!!!!!!!!! pic.twitter.com/AoGnnwypDc
— Bills Mafia Rochester (@BillsMafiaRoc) October 6, 2024
McDermott not challenging that is wild
— Bills Chat Podcast (@BillsChatPod) October 6, 2024
Sean McDermott is a coward
— Paul Ross (@RealPaulRoss) October 6, 2024
Really can't overstate how atrocious McDermott is at all game management/decision-making. Kincaid absolutely caught that ball. You NEED that conversion and you'll be in FG range (and have a 1st) if you get it. You have all three timeouts. Just no idea how you don't challenge.
— Carson Breber (@Carsobi) October 6, 2024
2:42 mins left. Great catch. Flag calls it incomplete and McDermott doesn’t challenge it. You’re down 14-3! Bro. Please fire McDermott. Please please please he sucks! #BillsMafia #BuffaloBills
— iLove”Democracy” (@FireKenBuffalo) October 6, 2024
Fire Sean McDermott.
Not challenging that no catch call is embarrassing.
This game is embarrassing WTF! @BuffaloBills #buffalobills #seanmcdermott #BillsMafia— Rachel Aloi (@RaCHeeech) October 6, 2024
That was a catch. I'm losing my patience with McDermott
— 🤷🏼♀️ (@disneywifee) October 6, 2024
Whoever is responsible for telling McDermott to challenge needs a new job.
— Gary Craig (@gcraig1) October 6, 2024
Please fire McDermott @BuffaloBills.
Clearly CLEARLY not the guy #BillsMafia
That's a catch all day worthy of replay DOWN 11— stardust (@whitey26515) October 6, 2024
Not knowing when to throw the challenge flag has been a real issue for Sean McDermott. One area he really hasn't grown into as a HC.
— Nate Geary (@NateGearySports) October 6, 2024
How do you not challenge that? McDermott challenges the most ridiculous plays but not that one? #BillsMafia
— DegenRoomSports (@DegenRoomSports) October 6, 2024
We had a shot at winning that challenge so of course Sean McDermott doesn't take it. Coward.
— bennthewave (@bennthewave) October 6, 2024
This article originally appeared on Rochester Democrat and Chronicle: Bills coach Sean McDermott should've challenged Dalton Kincaid catch