Advertisement

Move over Paul Skenes: Meet the first four rookies to start the MLB All-Star Game

Detroit Tigers right-hander Mark Fidrych was just the second rookie to start an MLB All-Star Game, dating back to the game’s inception in 1933. This year, in the 94th edition of the game, we’ll get the fifth, with Pittsburgh’s Paul Skenes set to toe the rubber for the National League on Tuesday night in Arlington, Texas. Here’s a quick look back at the four previous rookies to get the Midsummer Classic starting call.

July 30, 1962: Dave Stenhouse, Senators

Dave Stenhouse, of the Washington Senators.
Dave Stenhouse, of the Washington Senators.

The 28-year-old was the pick for the AL in the season’s second All-Star matchup — the AL and NL played a second game in four seasons (1959-62) to fund its pension plan — at Chicago’s Wrigley Field, three weeks after the first game. The Rhode Island native entered the game with a 2.73 ERA, 84 strkeouts and 57 walks over 132 innings, including a four-game stretch between the two All-Star games in which he had 26 strikeouts and allowed just eight runs in 37 innings, covering four complete games.

YOUNG GUNS GETTING HOT: Colt Keith, Justyn-Henry Malloy showing Detroit Tigers most important rookie skill: Grace

Stenhouse wasn’t quite as sharp in his only All-Star appearance (part of a three-season career); he got into an early jam with a hit batter, a Willie Mays single and a walk, but squeezed out of that and into the second. There, he was victimized by the opposing starter, Johnny Podres, who slapped a pitch into right field for a defense-aided double. Podres then scored on a single by leadoff hitter Dick Groat, for the only run scored on Stenhouse. He left trailing 1-0, but received a no-decision when Pete Runnels, pinch-hitting for Stenhouse, launched a solo homer in the third. Stenhouse’s final line: one run allowed on three hits and one walk with one strikeout in two innings.

July 13, 1976: Mark Fidrych, Tigers

Detroit Tigers pitcher Mark Fidrych on the mound
Detroit Tigers pitcher Mark Fidrych on the mound

Fidrych had become a national sensation in just 13 appearances, thanks to a 1.78 ERA and 0.997 WHIP while throwing complete games in 10 of his 11 starts. The star turn had already earned the confidence of AL manager Darrell Johnson, who told reporters, “So what if he’s so young, he’s not going to be scared out there.” The Red Sox skipper continued, “If he had any fear at all, he’d have shown it in our games. I haven’t seen any fear in him yet.” Fidrych didn’t show any fear before the game, but he did seem a bit flustered in a pregame availability, struggling with the microphone before noting the previously “most exciting thing”: “When I bought my mini-bike when I was 14 years old. Boy, that was something.”

On the Veterans Stadium turf in Philadelphia — away from his mini-bike — Fidrych found a new challenge, allowing a leadoff single to Pete Rose and a triple to No. 2 hitter Steve Garvey for an early deficit. But Fidrych rallied with three straight outs — though one, a groundout by George Foster, made it a 2-0 game — to get out of the inning. Fidrych’s second inning of work didn’t open much cleaner, with two singles and a passed ball to put runners on second and third with one out. But The Bird fanned opposing pitcher Randy Jones, and then got Rose to groundout back to the mound to strand the runners. His final line: two runs allowed on four hits with a strikeout over two innings while taking the loss. Still, Fidrych was anything but disappointed, telling reporters afterward, “How can I feel bad? Wow, I can’t believe I’m even here.

“It’s the biggest thrill of my life,” Fidrych continued. “Up until now, the biggest thing that’s happened to me was nothing. Now I’ve even got an All-Star ring. I never even had a high school ring.”

Aug. 9, 1981: Fernando Valenzuela, Dodgers

Oct 28, 1981, New York; USA;  FILE PHOTO Los Angeles Dodgers scout Mike Brito (left), and Los Angeles Dodgers pitcher Fernando Valenzuela (right) celebrate in the clubhouse after winning the 1981 World Series against the New York Yankees at Yankee Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Jayne Kamin-Oncea-USA TODAY Sports
Oct 28, 1981, New York; USA; FILE PHOTO Los Angeles Dodgers scout Mike Brito (left), and Los Angeles Dodgers pitcher Fernando Valenzuela (right) celebrate in the clubhouse after winning the 1981 World Series against the New York Yankees at Yankee Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Jayne Kamin-Oncea-USA TODAY Sports

Valenzuela ignited “Fernandomania” in Southern California and then the rest of the country with a first half in which he struck out 103 batters while walking 35 en route to a 2.45 ERA over 110 innings (including eight complete games) — despite the first half ending with a players’ strike in mid-June. So Valenzuela was well rested for his start at Cleveland Stadium — against Tigers right-hander Jack Morris — at 20 years, 281 days, as MLB resumed its action following labor peace.

Of course, so too were the AL vets facing Valenzuela, as the Angels’ Rod Carew singled off a 2-0 pitch to open the game. But Carew was soon caught stealing by NL catcher Gary Carter. After a single by No. 2 hitter Willie Randolph, Valenzuela settled down, getting George Brett and Dave Winfield to ground out on five pitches combined. That was it for the NL starter, who was pinch-hit for in the top of the second inning; he wound up with a no-decision — while throwing just 12 pitches — and the NL went on to win its 10th straight Midsummer Classic, 5-4.

July 11, 1995: Hideo Nomo, Dodgers

National League starting pitcher Hideo Nomo of Japan is surrounded by photographers as he sits in the dugout July 11 before the start of the 1995 All-Star Game at The Ballpark in Arlington, Texas. Nomo is the first Japanese-born player to appear in an All-Star Game.
National League starting pitcher Hideo Nomo of Japan is surrounded by photographers as he sits in the dugout July 11 before the start of the 1995 All-Star Game at The Ballpark in Arlington, Texas. Nomo is the first Japanese-born player to appear in an All-Star Game.

Although technically a rookie after coming to the Dodgers from Japan, Nomo was far from inexperienced. The 26-year-old had posted a 3.15 ERA over five seasons overseas to earn a $2.1 million contract from L.A. as well as a $2 million signing bonus. It was tough to argue he didn’t earn it once the season started in May (following the conclusion of the players’ 1994 strike and the owners’ 1995 lockout) — Nomo struck out 119 while posting a 1.99 ERA over 90 1/3 innings in 13 starts (including two complete games). Nomo was a bit wild, with 46 walks and four hit batters, but opponents hit just .158 off him, stymied by his forkball/fastball combo. As NL teammate Andres Galarraga put it, “You think it’s a forkball, and it’s a fastball. Then you think it’s a fastball, and it’s forkball. You just can’t recognize it.”

TRADE OR SIGN? Should the Detroit Tigers trade Tarik Skubal or extend him with Riley Greene?

Indeed, the AL batters were neutralized at The Ballpark in Arlington in Texas, with only No. 2 hitter Carlos Baerga, of Cleveland, managing a single. Nomo opened with a strikeout of Cleveland’s Kenny Lofton, then got Baerga attempting to steal and finished off the first inning with a strikeout of future Hall of Famer Edgar Martinez — though with a twist, it was Nomo’s curveball that got the out, not the heater or the fork. In the second, Nomo dusted Frank Thomas on a foul pop to the catcher, then struck out Cleveland’s Albert Belle. The only other AL’er to make contact was Baltimore’s Cal Ripken Jr., who lined out to right fielder Tony Gwynn to wrap up the inning, and Nomo’s outing. The final tally: one hit and three strikeouts in two innings, and one thrilled rookie: “This is more than what I expected, in terms of excitement,” Nomo told reporters afterward.

Contact Ryan Ford at rford@freepress.com. Follow him on X (which used to be Twitter, y’know?) @theford.

Read more on the Detroit Tigers and sign up for our Tigers newsletter.  

This article originally appeared on Detroit Free Press: Mark Fidrych's 1976 MLB All-Star Game start: From mini-bikes to rings