The Athletic's QB rankings put Derek Carr at the bottom of Tier 3
The New Orleans Saints quarterback situation has been the subject of controversy pretty much ever since Derek Carr signed with the team last offseason. Some fans swear up and down he is going to return to form and be a top 10-to-15 quarterback that the Saints need, others insist he is the worst player on the team and should be replaced. It's tough to find many takes that fall in the middle ground.
Ultimately the reality is somewhere between, and that might be the case for Carr in these quarterback rankings from The Athletic's Mike Sando. They put Carr on the lower end of their rating system. Here is their blurb about the Saints quarterback, where he ranks in Tier 3, and why:
Carr’s No. 20 ranking ties for his worst in 10 Tiers appearances. His 3.00 average is his worst since 2015, when Carr was entering his second season and on the upswing.
“He’s a 3 without (Jon) Gruden,” an offensive coach said. “Gruden could carry the mantel of all the leadership, where Carr could just snuggle up under the umbrella of Gruden. He is exposed now. He is the umbrella. It’s not comfortable. That takes away from his production.”
Carr’s statistics from last season aligned with Mayfield’s. Both led teams that finished 9-8. But voters see Carr as a declining player lacking the intangibles they think are strengths for Mayfield.
“We talk like Baker is some revitalization story,” a head coach said. “No, Baker has taken two teams to division titles. Derek Carr was in that same NFC South division with a better defense.”
The Saints ranked ninth and the Buccaneers were 18th last season in EPA per play on defense, per TruMedia.
“What holds (Carr) back is a lack of toughness in the pocket, and some of his decision making within the scheme,” another exec said.
According to their ranking system, Carr is tied for No. 20 on the list with Seattle Seahawks quarterback Geno Smith, which in my eyes is... honestly not the worst comparison of talent. However, Carr ranks second-worst in the NFC South among the starting quarterbacks. He's behind new addition Kirk Cousins (No. 13) and Baker Mayfield (No. 19), but ahead of Bryce Young (No.28). Out of the 30 starters listed, Cousins was the only one from the NFC South to make it into their "Tier 2" category, with the remainder falling below that mark.
Ultimately, this placement for Carr is not unjustified. Even if he does take a step forward this year, he has not done it yet, and the criticisms provided are generally an accurate assessment. Hopefully better days are on the horizon for Carr, for the sake of the Saints. But if not, who knows what the outcome of the team is for the 2024 season and potentially even beyond.
More 2024 season!
Saints cut Johnathan Abrams, a projected starter at safety
Shemar Jean-Charles is the first Saints cornerback to be let go
Saints waive rookie kicker Charlie Smyth, an International Player Pathway standout
Saints make somewhat surprise move in waiving rookie guard Kyle Hergel
Saints waive rookie draft pick Josiah Ezirim, a prime practice squad candidate
This article originally appeared on Saints Wire: The Athletic's QB rankings put Derek Carr at the bottom of Tier 3
